Closed Bug 551624 Opened 14 years ago Closed 1 month ago
Analyze why we're slower than V8 on Dromaeo regexp tests
When using simple regexps like |new RegExp("aaaaaaaaaa", "g")| (as the Dromaeo test does), we seem to be about 2x slower than Safari. A profile shows almost all the time is spent in the jit-generated code for the regexp. It would be interesting to compare the assembly we generate with the assembly jsc generates, with an eye towards improving our codegen somehow.
Is jsc's faster than v8's?
I don't know. On dromaeo v8 is faster, but I don't know whether the v8 I have here has that "cache stuff for dromaeo" workaround.... May be worth looking at both.
Summary: Analyze the assembly generated for simple regexps and compare to jsc's → Analyze the assembly generated for simple regexps and compare to JSC's and V8's
bz, I think this bug can be closed now that Yarr has landed on JM? Our regexp speed should be pretty similar to JSC's ;)
I just ran the dromaeo-object-regexp tests on JM+Yarr, Safari 5, Chrome Dev. Results: Us: 149.04runs/s Safari: 150.20runs/s Chrome: 278.99runs/s Comparison, in that order: http://dromaeo.com/?id=114965,114966,114963 Resummarizing to see what's up there. These tests especially: Compiled Variable Object Test Compiled Variable Object Empty Replace Compiled Variable Object 12 Char Replace Compiled Variable Object 12 Char Replace Function Compiled Capture Replace with Uppercase Capture Function Uncompiled Match Uncompiled Test Uncompiled Empty Replace Uncompiled 12 Char Replace Uncompiled Object Match Uncompiled Object Test Uncompiled Object Empty Replace Uncompiled Object 12 Char Replace
Summary: Analyze the assembly generated for simple regexps and compare to JSC's and V8's → Analyze why we're slower than V8 on Dromaeo regexp tests
Sad results =/ http://dromaeo.com/?id=203656,203653,203655 Nightly has IGC off these days, don't know if this affects the results.
http://dromaeo.com/?id=269974,269975,269976,269977 From left to right: Nightly, Chrome 62, Edge, Firefox 57 The fix from bug 1419785 made a huge boost in the last 4 tests of the list (the Uncompiled Object * tests). Firefox is faster or on par with Chrome and Edge on all tests except for the first two (around 33% slower on these).
Status: NEW → RESOLVED
Closed: 1 month ago
Resolution: --- → WORKSFORME
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.