Closed Bug 56012 Opened 26 years ago Closed 26 years ago

[mac] can't log into playboy

Categories

(SeaMonkey :: UI Design, defect, P1)

PowerPC
Mac System 8.5
defect

Tracking

(Not tracked)

VERIFIED WORKSFORME

People

(Reporter: pierre, Assigned: ekrock)

References

()

Details

(Keywords: platform-parity, top100, Whiteboard: [rtm-])

Per ekrock's request at the Layout meeting, I started surfing porn sites. Don't panic: we're still in the "soft" category. - Go to http://www.playboy.com/. If you have already been there, you're fine. Otherwise you are going to crash (see bug 56005). Just relaunch the app and go to Playboy again, you won't crash on this second attempt. - Click the "Playboy Cyber Club" link on the left - Click "Members - Enter the Club" ==> You get the Username/Password dialog - Enter random characters on both fields, click OK ==> Bug nothing happens. Instead, you should get the sign-on page of their payment site. I remember having seen the same problem on another site where the Username/ Password dialog wasn't working either. This bug doesn't happen on Win98. Assigned to XP-Apps but it could be XUL or Event Handling...
Nominating for RTM because it's a top100 site. Marking critical because, if I'm correct, the Username/Password doesn't work at all and this may prevent lots of folks from doing their everyday job.
Severity: normal → critical
Keywords: pp, rtm, top100
Priority: P3 → P1
not being able to login to playboy certainly prevents me from doing my job. what other porn sites can't i log into?... can this be given a [porn++]?
using today's comm branch bits [2000.10.10.10-n6] on OS 9.0, i don't think i run into this --i get the username/password dialog *twice* (i enter in bogus userid/passwd twice, too), then am routed to a Playboy Cyber Club site that says, "Sorry! The page you're looking for is part of the cyber club..." and contains a link to sign up for it. not sure if this belongs in xp apps. password management or security? or, even networking...? don't think this is single signon (just tested with a simple signon form and http authentication site).
QA Contact: sairuh
Here is a more PC site, one that really prevents me from doing my job: go to http://www.w3.org/Style/Group, same problem... Again, I tested with PR3 only on MacOS 9, not the branch tips.
sairuh: note that the behavior you describe is correct. That's what was expected. I can't download the real commercial build from ftp://sweetlou because I'm behind the firewall but I downloaded today's mozilla-mac-MN6 (2000-10-10-08) from mozilla.org. Result: everything works fine on the W3C site but on Playboy, I don't even get the Username/Password dialog anymore.
Sarah, serves your right for trying to go to the playboy site. You can't expect us to condone such actions on your part. :-)
rtm-. Why do I have this bug? Isn't this a signon issue?
Whiteboard: [rtm-]
Can't say with certainty that it is or is not a single-signon issue based on the symptoms reported. But, frankly, I doubt that it is.
nav triage team: giving back ekrock - as far as we can see, it is not part of xpapps or single signon as far as we can tell. Besides, Mac people don't surf porn ......
Assignee: don → ekrock
This will teach me to crack a joke at the Gecko all hands ... ;-> All right, fine. First of all, I went to playboy.com, and I have *not* been there before, and I didn't crash, so I can verify that bug 56005 is indeed fixed. Now, I went through pierre's steps. I don't have an account on this site, so I typed in random characters as stated. But I don't see "nothing" happen when I do this; instead, the log-in screen pops up again, suggesting that they've checked my bogus username/password, not found it, and pop up the dialog again. (Except: is that really possible, or is this a product bug where we're looping? Pierre, is this the bug? How would a server-side CGI cause the log-in dialog to pop up again? Normally, when you fail to log-in to sites, you see a new HTML page. If I click "cancel" instead of typing in bogus values, that's exactly what happens.) ... Oh for heaven's sake, I just realized that this bug is Mac-specific, and I'm running on WinNT, so I can't reproduce. Now I've surfed playboy.com for nothing! ... alright, installed N6 Mac today's build (2000-10-12-16) on Frank's Mac. Went through same steps. Once again, when I type in bogus values for username/password, the dialog pops up again. Marking WORKSFORME. The web is safe for adult surfers once again?
Status: NEW → RESOLVED
Closed: 26 years ago
Resolution: --- → WORKSFORME
I'm so sorry, Eric, it must have been an exhausting experience. I have an explanation for what I described in [2000-10-10 16:10]: when you click the "Members" link at http://cyber.playboy.com, the page is redirected to a secure page that displays the username/password dialog but since I used a Mozilla MN6 build - without encryption then - the redirection failed silently and no dialog was displayed. I'll file a bug against that: Mozilla should display an alert like "https is not a registered protocol".
I opened bug 56399 for connections to secure sites that silently fail in Mozilla builds.
Based on Pierre's comments, verifying WORKSFORME since the issue seems to have been the lack of HTTPS support in the Mozilla build he was using. Don't worry, Pierre. Now I can finally say that I've been paid to surf porn. I guess if you're working on browser development it's only a matter of time. ;->
Status: RESOLVED → VERIFIED
Product: Core → Mozilla Application Suite
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.