Closed Bug 89330 Opened 25 years ago Closed 25 years ago

Remove Motif port from tree

Categories

(SeaMonkey :: General, defect, P4)

x86
Linux

Tracking

(Not tracked)

RESOLVED FIXED
mozilla0.9.6

People

(Reporter: zuperdee, Assigned: netscape)

Details

Attachments

(1 file)

I admit, this may seem a little funny, considering I once wanted to ressurect the Motif port, but I think it should now be removed... I see absolutely no reason to keep it around anymore. Nobody uses it... Nobody builds it... Nobody owns it anymore (that I know of)... Nobody maintains it... Nobody CARES about it... Motif is generally a dying toolkit. I don't think the Linux/Unix market would mind if it were removed, especially since even HP/Sun include GNOME/GTK in their Unices. If nobody minds and everyone approves, I'd hereby like to request an opportunity to remove the Motif port from the tree. I'd LOVE to be the one that does it. Let us hereby save Mozilla some lines of code in the tree. :-)
hrm, i'd like to see it kept alive. i was working at one point to fix the string problems you reported, others seem to be doing the same work now so hopefully things will get better. if you do decide to remove it, please tag the motif code MOTIF_RIGHT_BEFORE_IT_WAS_KILLED or something so that people can ressurrect it.
I would like to see Motif port alive, too. Most code can be reused from Xlib-toolkit except some minor stuff: - use Motif DND API - use Motif clipboard API - use Xt/Motif "color management" API - use Motif/CDE datatyping for mimetype-->application mapping. CDE has a full database with this... it may be nice to use that - Motif Mozilla widget... :-) - ... etc. etc.
Goodness. Sounds like there is still a little support for it. I still don't understand *why*, however. Could someone explain this to me? I mean, is there ANYTHING feature-wise that the Motif port could potentially do that the other three Unix ports (Xlib, GTK, and Qt) cannot? Is there ANY Unix platform, be it proprietary OR open source, that the Xlib, GTK, or Qt ports will not run on at this point? Then, on those platforms that support all four, is there ANY reason whatsoever to pick Motif instead of Xlib, GTK, or Qt? In considering these questions, I would keep in mind that even some of the strongest original supporters of Motif/CDE, including HP, Sun , and The Open Group, are slowly deprecating the CDE/Motif duo in favor of the two major Unix desktop environments out there on the market today that are rapidly replacing CDE/Motif, like GNOME/GTK, or KDE/Qt. I happen to think even the Qt port makes more sense to support at this point than Motif. However, even then, since Mozilla has its very own XPWidget set at this point, what is the point of supporting ANY widget toolkit? Why bother using a full-fledged widget set, when Mozilla is now doing this all ITSELF?? Why not simply use raw Xlib, and bypass the extra layer of widgets? It would simplify things tremendously, and I think we have proven that Xlib has greater speed, performance, and code-size potential than any of the others, given that Mozilla has its own XPWidgets. If the support for Motif is really this strong however, then I am certainly willing to re-consider, and mark this bug WONTFIX, or even INVALID. If that is the case however, then bug 22266 (which is assigned to NOBODY) should be re-examined, as should bug 38637 (Roland, that will cover your Motif embedding widget), bug 77984 (DnD support), bug 78653, and last but not least, bug 89329. I will even be willing to check in patches for the Motif port, if you folks wish.
So here we are months later and the motif port is still dead. I posted a last call for motif to the newsgroups a few weeks ago and sentiment seemed to mainly be that motif was already dead. The code is bitrotten and those who have bothered to hack it enough to get it to compile, state that it still doesn't run and those hacks have never made their way back into the tree. Since there has been no active work on the motif port for the better part of 2 years now, it's time for it to finally leave the building. I've got a patch to remove the build references to motif and the following directories will be cvs removed: config/mkdetect gfx/src/motif widget/src/motif widget/timer/src/unix/motif webshell/embed/xlib/motif webshell/embed/xlib/xt webshell/tests/viewer/unix/motif
Comment on attachment 53185 [details] [diff] [review] Kiss motif good bye r=bryner
Attachment #53185 - Flags: review+
Taking the bug.
Assignee: zuperdee → seawood
Severity: normal → minor
Priority: -- → P4
Target Milestone: --- → mozilla0.9.6
rs=pavlov. check this in. :)
The tree was tagged with MOTIF_LAST_RITES before the removal. RIP Motif.
Status: NEW → RESOLVED
Closed: 25 years ago
Resolution: --- → FIXED
Hooray!! Thanks guys. I am now marking all Motif-related bugs WONTFIX. :-)
Product: Browser → Seamonkey
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.

Attachment

General

Created:
Updated:
Size: