151732 - Reply / Forward Strangly in MozillaMail (1.0 & 1.1Aplha)

Status: RESOLVED WORKSFORME

(MailNews Core :: Composition, defect)

Description

[Yeh You-Ying]

From Bugzilla Helper:
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Win98; en-US; rv:1.1a) Gecko/20020611
BuildID:    2002061104 (1.1 alpha)

While reply and forward some HTML message, Mozilla got problems...

Reproducible: Always
Steps to Reproduce:
1. Reply / Forward(as inline) some specifc HTML message (I'll attach the source
later)
2. Reply :  you will see the wrong placement of signature (from sender).
3. Forward: Strange composing message. Just a mass...

Actual Results:  Replay :  signature of orignal sender should be placed at the
buttom.
Forward : it should display correctly, and meaningfully.

If the OA contact needs the source sent directly to his mail box, please inform me.
My environment is Win98SE + 1.1 Alpha. 
1.0 + Win2000 also got the same problem.

Comment 1

[Yeh You-Ying]

Attachment: The outlook of the HTML message

Comment 2

[Yeh You-Ying]

Attachment: Message Source to Reproduce this issue

Comment 3

[Yeh You-Ying]

Attachment: While reply, the signature is placed wrongly

Comment 4

[Yeh You-Ying]

Attachment: While forward as inline, the composing is so strang. Message lots...

Comment 5

[Jean-Francois Ducarroz]

The problem with the wrong placment of the signature is a known problem
currently assigned to editor team if I am right. This is a visual problem during
the composition! If you send the message, the signature will correctly show at
the bottom of the message.

Comment 6

[Yeh You-Ying]

Hello Jean-Francois Ducarroz,

How about this case with "forwarding as inline" ?
Can you reproduce it ?
Any problem to reproduce this, please let me know.
Thanks a lot. 

Comment 7

[Jean-Francois Ducarroz]

When you send the message, does it appears ok on the receiver side?

Comment 8

[Jean-Francois Ducarroz]

Also, I wonder if you are not seeing bug 146584 too.

Comment 9

[Yeh You-Ying]

------- Additional Comment #7 From Jean-Francois Ducarroz  2002-07-08 11:01 -------
>>When you send the message, does it appears ok on the receiver side?

No,  forwarding (as inline) this kind of message, the appearance on the 
receiver side is not correct.

Comment 10

[Yeh You-Ying]

>>------- Additional Comment #8 From Jean-Francois Ducarroz  2002-07-08 11:32
-------
>>Also, I wonder if you are not seeing bug 146584 too.

I did not see bug#146584 before.
But I think it's not the same. 

Comment 11

[Yeh You-Ying]

Hello Jean-Francois Ducarroz,

I'll put another attachments to describe the issue later.
Thanks

Comment 12

[Yeh You-Ying]

Attachment: The orignal message appearance

The orignal message is made as following,
1. going to http://tw.news.yahoo.com/2002/07/08/relaxation/udn/3361922.html and
then copy
    the news I want
2. paste it into  composing window.
3. send out.

Comment 13

[Yeh You-Ying]

Attachment: The appearance of forwarded message on reciever side

Message just lost

Comment 14

[Yeh You-Ying]

Attachment: Message source of attachment id, 90561

Comment 15

[Yeh You-Ying]

Attachment: message source of the receiver side, also its the source of attachment is, 90562

Comment 16

[Jean-Francois Ducarroz]

Using Netscape 7.0 on either Mac OS X or Win2K, I am not able to reproduce this
problem. Here is what I did:

1) I went to http://tw.news.yahoo.com, click on an acticle
(http://tw.news.yahoo.com/2002/10/08/society/ctnews/3579214.html)
2) Copy the acticle content (from the title up to the link at the bottom)
3) Open an HTML compose window with a one line plain text signature
4) past the article content at the top
5) send the message (in HTML format) to myself
6) Get the message, it display correctly
7) Reply to the message, works fine, signatures at the bottom (both of them)
8) Forward the message (the one from step 6), again every thing is fine

Reporter, can you test using a recent build?

Comment 17

[Yeh You-Ying]

>>------- Additional Comment #16 From Jean-Francois Ducarroz 2002-10-08 14:43
-------
>>
>>Using Netscape 7.0 on either Mac OS X or Win2K, I am not able to reproduce this
>>problem. Here is what I did:
>>
>>1) I went to http://tw.news.yahoo.com, click on an acticle
>>(http://tw.news.yahoo.com/2002/10/08/society/ctnews/3579214.html)
>>2) Copy the acticle content (from the title up to the link at the bottom)
>>3) Open an HTML compose window with a one line plain text signature
>>4) past the article content at the top
>>5) send the message (in HTML format) to myself
>>6) Get the message, it display correctly
>>7) Reply to the message, works fine, signatures at the bottom (both of them)
>>8) Forward the message (the one from step 6), again every thing is fine
>>Reporter, can you test using a recent build?

Hello,

I followed your steps and got another problem as bug173012.
Now I use Mozilla 1.1 in Win2000.
Thanks :)

Comment 18

[Mike Cowperthwaite]

=> WFM per reporter's comment 17.