Open Bug 1904369 Opened 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago

Feed still present in 3-pane view after unsubscribing from a feed via the Feed Subscriptions window

Categories

(Thunderbird :: General, defect)

Thunderbird 128
defect

Tracking

(Not tracked)

People

(Reporter: babolivier, Unassigned)

References

(Blocks 1 open bug)

Details

Attachments

(1 file)

See the screen recording attached. After removing a feed using the Feed Subscription window, the parent folder that was created when adding the feed remains, and the feed remains browsable (and outside of the Trash folder) using the folder pane. As quickly shown in the recording, the parent folder seemingly cannot be removed using the Feed Subscriptions window.

I used https://blog.thunderbird.net/feed/ in this test.

The UI is somewhat confusing, but it it expected that the folder remains. The folder may contain other feeds as well, and even after unsubscribing you may want to hold on to the existing items.

Summary: Feed still present after removing it via the Feed Subscriptions window → Feed folder still present after unsubscribing from a feed via the Feed Subscriptions window

I mentioned the feed folder sticking around as an aside I found confusing (I should have been clearer, apologies), but the actual bug is that the feed itself can still be viewed and browsed from the 3-pane view even after removing it using the Feed Subscriptions window. The only way to actually remove it is by using the "Delete" action from the folder pane.

Summary: Feed folder still present after unsubscribing from a feed via the Feed Subscriptions window → Feed still present after unsubscribing from a feed via the Feed Subscriptions window

The data remains, but there is not any way of knowing which items originated from which feed (especially if you put all feeds in the same folder). And, people may want to keep that feed data. A dialog asking if the data should also be removed may be appropriate though.

Right, I think there's probably some visual and UX rehaul to do as well because it's really confusing. When adding a feed via the Feed Subscriptions UI, a folder is automatically created between the feeds account and the feed itself, but it doesn't appear in the 3-pane UI (since I'm assuming we do something in the frontend to simplify the UI and make the folder appear as the feed). So I naturally assumed that this was the feed itself, and removing it using the subscriptions window would remove it from the 3-pane view as well. I understand now that what I see in the folder pane is this "modified" view on the folder and by removing the feed I only removed a source to use to update the folder.

Summary: Feed still present after unsubscribing from a feed via the Feed Subscriptions window → Feed still present in 3-pane view after unsubscribing from a feed via the Feed Subscriptions window
Blocks: tb128found
You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.

Attachment

General

Created:
Updated:
Size: