Closed
Bug 687809
(mathmlinmathjax)
Opened 13 years ago
Closed 1 month ago
[meta] MathML in MathJax
Categories
(Core :: MathML, defect)
Core
MathML
Tracking
()
RESOLVED
WONTFIX
People
(Reporter: fredw, Unassigned)
References
(Depends on 2 open bugs, Blocks 1 open bug, )
Details
(Keywords: meta)
MathJax is a popular Javascript library to display mathematical formulas in any browser. For Firefox, the native MathML rendering is used. MathJax is also able to convert LaTeX to MathML. However, our MathML support has some issues that prevent the markup generated by MathJax to render correctly. This makes some people switch to MathJax's layout engine and it's a shame. This is a tracking bug for issues that have been reported by MathJax folks. It looks like more and more people are using MathML throughout this library and so it seems important to fix these bugs.
Reporter  
Updated•13 years ago

Depends on: mlabeledtr, 508120, 685628, mpaddedvoffset, negativenamedspaces, 687807, 114635, uprightmi, 491384
Reporter  
Updated•13 years ago

Reporter  
Updated•13 years ago

Depends on: mlabeledtrsupport
Reporter  
Updated•13 years ago

Depends on: rowcolumnspacing, maction
Reporter  
Comment 3•13 years ago


MathJax also has its own Open Type fonts, which look closer to LaTeX fonts and thus are often preferred by MathJax users. That may be interesting to see if we can support them. They do not seem to contain an OpenType MATH table, though.
Reporter  
Comment 4•13 years ago


Adding bug 468568. See MathJax issue tracker: https://github.com/mathjax/MathJax/issues/13
Depends on: 468568
Reporter  
Comment 5•13 years ago


(In reply to Frédéric Wang from comment #4) > Adding bug 468568. > See MathJax issue tracker: > https://github.com/mathjax/MathJax/issues/13 Sorry it is https://github.com/mathjax/MathJax/issues/172
Reporter  
Comment 6•13 years ago


(In reply to [Baboo] from comment #1) > Printing issues reproducible using MathJax too? I've added dependencies to bug 697053 and bug 468568.
Reporter  
Updated•13 years ago

Depends on: mathjaxfonts
Reporter  
Updated•12 years ago

Depends on: mtablewidth
Reporter  
Comment 8•12 years ago


Another bug due to bad width computation (testcase to reduce): https://github.com/mathjax/MathJax/issues/88
Reporter  
Comment 9•12 years ago


Things to do for MathJax fonts:  horizontal braces (see bug 701758 comment 2)  add rules in mathml.css (see bug 701758 comment 13)  allow use of downloadable fonts (see bug 701758 comment 17)
Reporter  
Updated•12 years ago

Depends on: mathmlfonts
Reporter  
Updated•12 years ago

Depends on: mathjaxinmathtext
Reporter  
Updated•12 years ago

Alias: mathmlinmathjax
Reporter  
Updated•12 years ago

Depends on: linebreaksAroundMath, mathmllinebreaking
Reporter  
Comment 10•12 years ago


MathJax has three commands \mathtip, \texttip and \toggle that generate maction elements: http://cdn.mathjax.org/mathjax/latest/unpacked/extensions/TeX/action.js
Comment 11•12 years ago


I noticed that Firefox on snow leopard is extremely slow with MathJax content. Please open this page http://math.elinkage.net/showthread.php?tid=102&pid=670#pid670 with various browsers. Stop and reload is helps but it's just strange why the page cannot load in the first request
Reporter  
Comment 12•12 years ago


(In reply to elim.qiu from comment #11) > I noticed that Firefox on snow leopard is extremely slow with MathJax > content. > > Please open this page > http://math.elinkage.net/showthread.php?tid=102&pid=670#pid670 with various > browsers. > > Stop and reload is helps but it's just strange why the page cannot load in > the first request This bug is to track MathML issues related to MathJax. Apparently, the page you refer to seems to use MathJax's HTMLCSS rendering so your problem would better be handled on the MathJax side or, if one can determine a precise reason of slowness in Firefox, as a dependency of bug 745687. Anyway, MathJax's rendering engine is entirely written in Javascript and that's why it is so slow compared to the native rendering of browsers, especially for pages that contain a lot of formulas. Maybe MathJax's code can still be optimized (improvements have been made in version 2.0, but the page you mention still uses version 1.1) and Javascript execution in browsers can be made faster. But this will never be as efficient as Gecko's native rendering. So your problem will really be fixed by making MathJax use Firefox's MathML by default again, which is now the main goal of the present bug entry. Other possible reasons:  download time of Web fonts: to fix that, you can install local version of MathJax/STIX fonts on your system.  LaTeX parsing: could be made faster if done before serving the page. BTW, for those following this bug, Wikipedia now has an experimental MathJax option: http://groups.google.com/group/mozilla.dev.tech.mathml/browse_frm/thread/0ec9c3ccaee4964c#
Reporter  
Updated•12 years ago

Reporter  
Updated•12 years ago

Depends on: stretchmtdmath
Reporter  
Updated•11 years ago

Reporter  
Updated•10 years ago

Updated•5 years ago

Summary: MathML in MathJax → [meta] MathML in MathJax
Updated•2 years ago

Severity: normal → S3
Reporter  
Comment 13•1 month ago


Mass WONTFIX for bugs related to legacy features that are not part of MathML Core (and with no plan to add them) or corresponding meta bugs. Please see bug 1495813 for the new meta bug.
Status: NEW → RESOLVED
Closed: 1 month ago
Resolution:  → WONTFIX
You need to log in
before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.
Description
•